Hello Reader,
Have you ever encountered the excruciating grip of muscle cramps during a race? If you’ve been following our previous Coaching Prof instalments, you know that I certainly did. These moments of agony can leave individuals bewildered and desperately searching for answers.
So, what triggers these unwelcome cramps?
Let’s start by examining the shortlist of common explanations offered:
Few out there will tell you what the science actually supports. That is, that your cramping happened because you didn't pace yourself properly relative to your preparation. Put another way, you went too hard relative to your prior training efforts — a concept known as the neuromuscular hypothesis.
A somewhat recent study by Giuriato et al. in 2018 meticulously analyzed the literature surrounding the two most prevailing theories — dehydration/electrolyte versus neuromuscular. From a pool of 424 potential papers, they identified 69 valid studies. The research overwhelmingly suggested that cramping is fundamentally a neuromuscular problem. Muscle cramp arises from an imbalance between the excitatory drive (your brain’s insistence on pushing forward) and the inhibitory drive (the part of your nervous system that isn’t quite ready for the physical demand being placed on it).
The result? Cramp. Your body’s protective mechanism to halt further damage.
Now, let’s delve briefly into the key components involved in your neuromuscular system to try to understand more. This is a busy figure but its the best we could do to try to make a complex issue somewhat simplified.
You'll note two key neuromuscular sensors around your muscles and tendons — the muscle spindle and Golgi tendon organ. Muscle spindles are like stretch sensors in your muscles that inform your brain about how much your muscles are stretching or changing in length, helping control muscle movements. In contrast, Golgi tendon organs act as tension sensors, signaling your brain when your muscles are under excessive force or strain to prevent injury by regulating muscle tension. Both these specialized structures talk with one another and are crucial for coordinating muscle activity and protecting your body during physical activities. Of course, when you pace too hard in a race relative to what you are prepared for, the two sensors organize to sound the alarm as needed, and cramp occurs to prevent further damage.
So. If you’ve experienced these cramps, what measures can you take to prevent them in the future? While a nutritionist might advise you to increase sodium intake, switch to a different nutritional product, or consume more fluids, few are likely to emphasize the importance of better preparation and pacing. But that, my friend, is the truth of the matter.
In Athletica, you’ll notice that many training sessions are designed to mimic race conditions precisely. Training in the same conditions you’ll be racing in calibrates your neuromuscular system (above) to align with your race-day capabilities, reducing the likelihood of cramping. If cramping has occurred in your past, it may be useful to retrospectively look back at your Workout Reserve, as seeing this number dive to the basement early in your race could give insight into how deep you went relative to the past.
But what about sodium intake during an event? (i.e., "my clothes are caked in sodium and I'm a heavy sweater"). Well, we had the privilege of hosting Tim Noakes on our Podcast, and we posed this question to him. He emphasized that daily sodium intake is indeed beneficial, but intake during the event itself is unlikely to make a significant difference — neither helping nor hindering. Moreover, relying on someone to determine your sweat rate or sodium excretion level lacks a scientific basis. Your sweat glands, or eccrine glands, regulate blood sodium levels to maintain homeostasis. If you find sodium residue on your clothes, it indicates an adequate sodium balance in your body, with the excess being excreted to maintain an equilibrium.
Let’s revisit my own data, where I meticulously measured both sodium levels and race performance. Even though I diligently consumed fluids (too much), my sodium levels remained constant until the end of the race when I stopped. It’s essential to note that I too experienced severe cramping. The crucial revelation here for me is that I was pushing well beyond my physical capabilities, as evidenced by my rising heart rate leading up to the cramp. In a well-prepared condition, my heart rate would have stabilized in sync with my running pace, a state now referred to as ‘durability’. My motivation was at its peak, with numerous spectators and monitors fuelling my ego’s desire to impress. I pushed beyond my capacity. Cramping simply saved me to fight another day.
In summary, it’s important to remember that the primary cause of cramping is often tied to pacing in relation to preparation level, rather than any nutritional factors. When you get back to the drawing board after succumbing to this disappointment, keep this science in mind. I did, and was happy for it.
Paul Laursen, PhD
Smarter training starts here. Athletica’s newsletters deliver science-backed insights, expert tips, and AI-powered training updates for endurance athletes of all levels. Catch up on past editions and subscribe to stay ahead in your training journey.
Hello June has felt like a month where everything we talk about came to life. Iris Nafshi, a researcher who studied moms training for Ironman while raising kids and finishing a PhD. A virtual 5K that pulled in athletes from all corners of the globe on the same weekend. A blog MJ wrote a couple years ago about why "balance" is a myth, and why MJ still stands by every word. Three different things. Same idea underneath: big goals are possible in a full life. They just require a different kind of...
Dear Reader, I remember learning about energy systems in school. Professor Paul Gastin's diagram was the gold standard: a clean picture of how much each system contributed depending on effort duration. You've probably seen similar. ATP-PCr, Glycolysis/lactic, Aerobic; each with its lane, each with its moment. Gastin (2001)'s classic energy system interaction model for maximal exercise. Then I watched a film that added the piece Gastin hadn't for me. That these systems are never one or the...
Hello Reader, Sebastian Sawe ran 1:59:30 in London last weekend. Three men finished under the previous world record for the marathon. Coaches and media publicly credited 100–120 g/hr of carbohydrate. The running internet promptly lost its mind. So on the Athlete’s Compass Podcast this week, Paul Warloski and I took the question head-on: should you be eating like Sawe? Short answer: no. But the longer answer is more interesting. And it points somewhere the sports nutrition field hasn’t quite...